Are you a Squishmallow enthusiast or simply looking for the rarest and most valuable companions? If so, you’re in for a treat!

In this blog post, we’ll dive into the world of the top 17 rarest Squishmallows in 2023, exploring their unique features, backstories, and what makes them so incredibly sought-after.

We’ll also answer the question, “What is the rarest Squishmallow?”

From Jack the Cat, the ultimate rarity, to exclusive finds like Avery the Duck and Fania the Purple Owl, you’ll discover the plushies that have captured the hearts of collectors and skyrocketed in value.

So, let’s embark on this exciting journey and uncover the most fascinating and rare Squishmallows out there!

Key Takeaways

  • Discover the ultimate prize for Squishmallow collectors - 17 rare characters, including Jack the Cat and Avery the Duck!
  • Get excited to hunt down exclusive finds like Fania & Blossom or regional exclusives like Lenora & Gertrude.
  • Don’t miss out on top 3 rarest Squishmallows of 2023: Jack, Avery & Fania plus Cameron as first ever character created by KellyToy!

The Rarest Squishmallows of 2023

The thrill of the hunt for rare Squishmallows has captured the hearts of collectors and plush toy enthusiasts alike.

With over 1,000 unique characters to collect, including adorable frog Squishmallow designs, it’s no wonder these cuddly companions have taken the world by storm.

But which are the rarest of them all? This article will introduce you to the 17 rarest Squishmallows of 2023, including:

  • Jack the Cat
  • Heather the Dragonfly
  • Fania the Purple Owl
  • Avery the Fox
  • Philippe the Penguin
  • Blossom the Bunny
  • Santino the Sloth
  • Connor the Crab

These exclusive plushies have become the ultimate prize for collectors, with their limited availability and skyrocketing estimated values in the secondary market.

Jack the Cat: The Ultimate Rarity

Jack the Cat, the 500th Squishmallow ever made, holds the title of the rarest Squishmallow, with only 500 units produced.

This black cat plushie features unique attributes, such as closed white eyes, white whiskers, and a tiny pink mouth.

What makes Jack the Cat so special is the exclusive gold 500 tag on its left ear, making it a true collector’s item.

Jack the Cat’s rarity and exclusivity have driven up its auction prices, with collectors willing to pay top dollar to add this cuddly feline to their Squishmallow collection.

So if you ever come across Jack the Cat, keep in mind that you’re looking at the ultimate rarity in the Squishmallow world!

Exclusive Finds: Avery, Fania, and Philippe

Collectors have also been captivated by the exclusive trio of Squishmallows.

  • Avery the Duck: a cheerful green and brown duck with fluffy wings, a tan-colored belly, and a bright green mallard head. It was released in six different sizes and quickly sold out, making it hard to get hold of.
  • Fania the Purple Owl: a cute purple owl with a soft and squishy body. It has become a favorite among collectors.
  • Philippe the Frog: a lovable frog with a bright green body and big round eyes. It is highly sought after by Squishmallow enthusiasts.

These exclusive Squishmallows have gained a lot of attention and are a must-have for collectors.

Fania the Purple Owl, on the other hand, is the most expensive Squishmallow, with her price soaring around $500 USD in the market.

As for Philippe the Frog, this adorable green frog with a white belly and cute pink heart-shaped cheeks is an exclusive Squishmallow for Valentine’s Day, making it rare due to its limited availability.

In comparison, the pink and white hedgehog Squishmallow has a more common presence on the market.

Unique Characters: Blossom, Santino, and Connor

In the Squishmallow universe, Blossom the Sheep, Santino the Platypus, and Connor the Cow are standout characters due to their uniqueness.

Blossom, an exciting sheep Squishmallow with a cream-colored face and gorgeous gold fluff edges, clutches her hooves around a tiny rainbow with woolen clouds.

This cute plushie was made through a limited partnership between Kellytoy and Justice, and since Justice folded in 2021, Blossom will never be manufactured again, making her incredibly rare.

Santino the Platypus is an exciting brown Squishmallow with a dazzling white belly and gleaming black eyes.

Released in 2020, Santino has an estimated value of $950, making him one of the rarest brown body Squishmallows among the thousand-plus plushies from Squishmallows.

Connor the Cow, on the other hand, is an amazing Squishmallow released in 2017. He’s part of the 2022 Easter Squad and Harvest Squad and is described as an athlete who is very competitive.

Regional Exclusives: Lenora, Gertrude, and Chanel

Some squashmallows are even more exclusive due to their regional availability. Lenora the Loon, Gertrude the Goose, and Chanel are Canadian-exclusive Squishmallows released in 2019.

Their limited release has resulted in high demand among collectors, with resellers asking between $200-$350 for them due to their rare status.

These region-specific Squishmallows highlight the brand’s diversity and wide-reaching appeal, as collectors around the world scramble to acquire their favorite characters.

The rarity and exclusivity of these plushies make them even more desirable, adding to the collectability factor of Squishmallows.


Store-Specific Releases: Mariah, Brigita, and Lucille

The hunt for Squishmallows gains an additional level of exclusivity with store-specific releases. Some examples include:

  • Mariah the Tie Dye Lamb, which is an Aldi grocery store exclusive
  • Brigita the Cheetah, with her stunning light green spots and black eyes, which is a Target-exclusive Squishmallow
  • Lucille the Seal, who is part of the Sealife Squad and is one of only four seal squirrels, making her the rarest of them all.

These exclusive releases make it even more challenging to complete a Squishmallow collection, as collectors need to keep an eye out for specific stores and promotions to acquire these cuddly companions.

The thrill of the hunt only adds to the excitement and appeal of these plush toys.

Social Media Sensations: Stacy and Golden Hans

Some Squishmallows have ridden the wave of social media popularity to fame. Stacy the Squid is one such example, gaining immense popularity through TikTok.

This 24-inch Squishmallow, released only in Canada, has reached auction prices of up to $356.69.

To celebrate selling 100 million Squishmallows, the company released a limited edition golden version of Stacy the Squid, called Golden Hans.

This exclusive plushie highlights the impact of social media on the popularity and rarity of certain Squishmallows, making them even more sought-after by collectors.

Understanding Squishmallow Rarity

What factors contribute to a Squishmallow’s rarity? The rarity of a squashmallow can be influenced by various factors, such as:

  • Limited production numbers
  • Special editions or collaborations
  • Exclusive releases
  • Unique designs or features
  • Limited availability in certain regions or stores
  • Rare or hard-to-find characters
  • Special tags or markings

For example, the ultimate rarity, Jack the Black Cat, had only 500 units produced with a gold 500 tag on its left ear.

Limited edition Squishmallows, like Blossom the Sheep, are also considered rare squishmallow finds, with their rarity label indicating a specific number of units manufactured before the design is permanently discontinued.

Understanding these factors can help collectors identify rare and valuable Squishmallows, adding to the excitement of the hunt.

Hug Mee Squishmallows: A Cuddly Twist

The HugMee collection introduces a delightful line of Squishmallows, designed with hands, feet, or paws for enhanced cuddling potential. These plushies come in various sizes, including:

  • 10-inch
  • 12-inch
  • 14-inch
  • 18-inch

They are made with super soft, ultrasoft materials, perfect for creating a soft pink heart.

HugMee Squishmallows are renowned for their cuddly and huggable nature, making them the perfect companions for both kids and adults. Their unique design features include:

  • Extra-long arms for extra huggability
  • Super soft and squishy material
  • Adorable animal designs with cute expressions
  • Various sizes and colors to choose from

These features add a cuddly twist to the already popular blue Squishmallow collection, including the adorable duck squishmallow and the plain cinnamon swirl design.

Limited Edition Squishmallows: The Rarity Scale

A Rarity Scale, featuring tiers like Ultra Rare, Special Edition, and Select Series, aids collectors in identifying enticing limited edition Squishmallows.

A Squishmallow is a limited edition character with a rarity label. This design has a specific number of units manufactured before it is permanently discontinued.

The Rarity Scale provides a valuable tool for collectors to determine the rarity and potential value of their Squishmallows, making it essential for those looking to complete their collection or invest in these cuddly companions.

Top 3 Rarest Squishmallows Recap

In summary, the three rarest Squishmallows of 2023 are Jack the Black Cat, Avery the Duck, and Fania the Purple Owl.

These exclusive and sought-after plushies showcase the diversity, appeal, and collectability of Squishmallows, making them the ultimate prize for collectors and enthusiasts alike.

The First Ever Squishmallow: Cameron the Calico Cat

The Squishmallow phenomenon took off in 2017, marked by the debut of its first-ever character, Cameron the Calico Cat, or Cam the Cat. Created by the KellyToy company, Cameron features:

  • A white and orange tabby cat design
  • A pink nose
  • A pink and white striped tail
  • A big smile
  • Bright blue eyes

Cameron the Calico Cat marked the beginning of an ever-growing collection of over 1,000 unique and cuddly Squishmallow characters.

Its popularity has only grown since its inception, capturing the hearts of collectors and plush toy enthusiasts around the globe.


As we’ve explored the world of rare Squishmallows, we’ve discovered the incredible diversity and appeal of these cuddly companions.

From the ultimate rarity, Jack the Cat, to regional exclusives like Lenora the Loon, Gertrude the Goose, and Chanel, these plushies have captured the hearts of collectors and skyrocketed in value.

As you continue your Squishmallow hunting adventures, keep an eye out for these elusive treasures and cherish the excitement of the hunt!

Need to add to your collection of Squishmallows?  Check out some of our top picks. You never know what you might find!

Best Squishmallow Pet Beds: Ultimate Comfort for Your Furry Friend
Dive into our comprehensive review and find out why these Squishmallow beds are a game-changer for pet comfort.
Disney Squishmallows: From Mickey to Elsa, The Plushies You Need!
Discover the charm and allure of Disney Squishmallows, the softest and most huggable characters. Perfect for kids and collectors alike.
Kitty Cuddles Are Even Better With These 11 Cat Squishmallows!
What could be better than a squishy, soft, and adorable Cat Squishmallow? Pounce on these before they are gone!
Don’t Be A Dog Gone Fool – Get These 26 Dog Squishmallows Before They Sell Out!
These adorable dog squishmallows will have your friends and family howling with delight. Get yours before they are gone!
Explore the World of Shark Squishmallows: A Collector’s Guide
Dive into the fascinating universe of shark Squishmallows with our comprehensive guide. Discover rare finds and how to grow your collection.
From Moo to You: Why These 10 Cow Squishmallows Make the Best Gifts!
You know what they say, everything’s better down on the farm! And that definitely includes Cow Squishmallows!
7 Bat Squishmallows: The Most Fun You’ll Ever Have With A Blood Sucker!
Do you like bats that are soft, squeezable and totally adorable? Well, then you’re going to love Bat Squishmallows!
10 Bigfoot Squishmallows: The Ultimate Cuddle Buddies!
Bigfoot is one of the most elusive creatures on earth, but now you can have your very own Squishmallow version to cuddle with.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the top 3 rarest Squishmallows?

Behold the top 3 rarest Squishmallows - Jack the Black Cat, Avery the Duck, and Fania the Purple Owl - each with their own charming personalities and stories!

These Squishmallows are sure to bring joy to any collector, with their unique designs and soft textures. They are perfect for cuddling, playing, and collecting.

These rare Squishmallows are sure to be a hit with any fan of the Squishmallows.

What is the rarest Squishmallow and how much is it worth?

Jack the Black Cat is the world’s rarest squashmallow, with only 500 of them available and a price ranging up to $1,299.99 on eBay! What a steal for such an adorable little kitty!

What is the most common Squishmallow ever?

Cam the Cat is the most popular Squishmallow, being one of the first characters released and selling out online in two hours. She is an iconic personality that appeals to all ages! Cam is a beloved character with her own unique style and personality. She is a symbol of fun and friendship, and her bright colors and big eyes make her instantly recognizable. Her popularity has made her a staple of the Squash community.

Is Bubba Squishmallow rare?

Bubba the Squishmallow is super rare and only available rarely - a true collector’s item! Snuggle up with this ultra soft, cuddly cow today!

What makes a Squishmallow rare?

Squishmallows are considered rare when they are limited edition or come with exclusive silver tags - making them collectible and sought after! These limited edition and exclusive Squishmallows are highly sought after and can be collected as a hobby. They can be found in stores, online, or even traded with other collectors. Collecting Squishmallows can be fun.